Proof*: Area of a Trapezium (Trapezoid US)

At the Don Steward event last weekend, Don demonstrated how the formula for a trapezium can be derived in different ways. He asked the participants if they could figure out one of them, and my fantastic student Beth came up with this beauty:

bl_proof

What a star!

Following on from that, Don pointed out that a trapezium is in fact just the bottom of a larger triangle:

trapezium_1

Trapezium_2

He then conjectured the possibility of a proof using that triangle. He asked the audience. If you want to stop here, and go play with some maths, be my guest. Otherwise continue reading…

 

 

So I volunteered the beginnings of a potential solution. I saw straight away that there *must* be a proof using similar triangles, by dropping a perpendicular line from the apex of the triangle, thus forming two pairs of similar right-angled triangles (yellow and small pink,  white and big pink):

trapezium_3

He liked the idea, pressed me to take it further, but that was as far as I got. He challenged me to work it out after the session.

Well, after Beth posted her proof on Twitter yesterday, I was reminded of the challenge! So late last night I opened a pad of paper, got out a pen, and started scribbling…

First I need some labels:

Proof Pt1

Proof Pt2

Proof Pt3

Ok So we’re going to work with the two left-hand side Right Angled Triangles:

Proof Pt4

Now we know the pink and yellowpink triangles are similar, so :

proof_maths_1

I have an expression for h2, which is important, because that’s the letter I don’t want for my final formula.

So to find the area of the bit that’s important to me, I need to subtract the area of the pink triangle from the larger triangle (I called it yellowpink earlier). I also need to substitute h2 with my new expression:

c2

correction

Now I’ll deal with the other triangles:

Proof Pt5

Well this is exactly the same method, and will get an almost identical expression, but with b2 and a2 instead of b1 and a1:

proof_

So the total area (ie, the area of the trapezium) is these two expressions added together:

proof_last

Very satisfying!

My original version, which I didn’t simplify until much later on in the proof, and used slightly daft lettering for, is here (click for enlargement):

2015-03-07 00.56.36

* edit … until John Golden brilliantly points this out to me! …

B_gbG-zW8AApmmh

There’s a hole in my bucket!

So dropping the perpendicular needs to go. However, the similar triangles can stay. We’ll just use two of them this time. Extend the lines to make a big triangle, and you have two similar (albeit not right-angled) triangles. Therefore the same rules apply, and we only need do everything once:

adj

 

Advertisements

11 thoughts on “Proof*: Area of a Trapezium (Trapezoid US)

  1. Not sure if you need to split triangle into left and right sides.
    By similar triangles (h2-h)/a =h2/b since perpendicular height from base will be in proportion to the sides and in particular the base
    Rearranging h2/a – h2/b = h/a
    Take out h2 from LHS gives h2 (1/a -1/b) = h/a
    Putting 1/a -1/b over a common denominator gives h2 (b – a)/ab = h/a
    So h2 = b h / (b-a)
    Area of trapezium = whole triangle less top triangle = b h2 / 2 – a (h2 – h) / 2
    = (b – a) h2 / 2 + a h / 2
    Substitute formula for h2
    Area =( (b-a) . b h / (b-a) ) / 2 + a h / 2
    Cancelling (b-a) gives
    Area = b h / 2 + a h /2 = (a+b) h / 2

  2. Clearly an easy way to derive the formula for a trapezium’s area is to label the vertices of the trapezium A, B, C and D where AB is the base say and DC is parallel to AB. Draw a line from A to the opposite corner (C). The line AC splits the trapezium into two triangles ABC (with base length b and height h) and DCA (an upside down triangle with base a and height h). Area of ABC = bh/2, area of DCA is ah/2. Adding gives (a+b)h/2

  3. Linear variation give you another way to see the formula for h2 (and, as noted above, you don’t need to cut into left and right sides): if it takes a linear relationship h distance to go from b length to a, then how long does it take to go from a to 0? Simple slope formula gives you ah/(b-a).
    Assume you’ve seen another approach where you make a paralellogram out of your original quadrilateral and a copy that has been reflected through a line parallel to the two parallel sides.

  4. A nice alternative if you want;

    Start with your trapezium; have another copy rotated 180degrees.

    Push it together.

    The top and bottom are now of length a+b and the height is the same

    Shape is a parallelogram so area base x height
    Which is really (a+b) x height

    Obviously the parallelogram is formed by two identical trapezia so multiply by 1/2

    (I tend to teach area of parallelograms first then area of triangles linked to that) and then area of trapezium linked back to parallelograms.

  5. Hi. Another approach is to use integration. Rotate the triangle 90deg clockwise so that its apex is at the origin and the perpendicular height is along the positive x-axis. Integrate y from x=h2 – h to x=h2 (where y=b, the short parallel side when x=h2-h and y=a, the long parallel side when x=h2). Substitute t=x-(h2-h) noting that dt/dx=1. Easy to see (with a diagram!) that y=b+t*(b-a)/h. At x=h2-h we get t=0 and at x=h2 we get t=h. So integrate b+t*(b-a)/h to get [bt + (a-b)*t^2/(2h)] from t=0 to t=h. This = bh + (a-b)*h^2/2h = bh + (a-b)*h/2 = ((a+b)/2)*h
    Separately I took a look at Don Stewards powerpoints you kindly posted recently on this site. Very interesting. I particularly liked the problem in the 2nd powerpoint on cutting up lengths of cardboard into three to get the average length of two pieces to equal the length of the 3rd.
    Back to the trapezium ‘though it is interesting to draw an analogy between calculating the area of a trapezium and summing an arithmetic series – average of first term and last term times the number of terms.

  6. Pingback: Proof*: Area of a Trapezium (Trapezoid US) | Solve My Maths | Learning Curve

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s